Constructed in 1872 on the southeast corner of Church and Main Streets, this building was the third church for the Methodist congregation, which organized in 1808. A late Victorian brick building with stone details, the building combines Gothic style architecture with Romanesque detailing, the appearance united by round arches over the windows and doors. Decorative corbeling (structural pieces of stone, wood, or metal jutting out from a wall to carry weight) lie parallel with the roof line, and a molded cornice and eave add to the distinctive embellishment of the building.

The interior of the sanctuary is a large, open room with a plaster paneled ceiling, two rows of pews with a center aisle and three large arches on the west end by the altar and pulpit platform. A balcony, paired stained glass windows, chair railing, suspended cathedral lights, and large crown molding add to the details on the sanctuary.

The stained glass windows add to the beauty of this church. Just below the roof peak is a circular stained glass medallion showing the date of construction - 1872.

A story is told that, in 1888, it took three teams of horses to hoist the church bell up into the steeple. A scaffold was built on which to rest the bell. The workers also had to build the steeple taller before they installed the bell.

A 1956 addition, built in the location of a previous addition, was constructed of brick with similar details to match the exterior of the 1872 structure.